Back To All BlogsBlog 239 of 282Prev   Next


SCAPEGOAT SPOTTED ON ORANGE GROVE

Published On 04-13-2012 , 5:03 AM



Long before cell phones were in everyone's hands or home telephones were called landlines, phone booths could be found on many a street corner.

Ah, yesteryear. Much has changed since the old days. But too much has remained the same.

The tall white guy with blond hair had a knife to my teenage daughter's neck as he pushed open the door of a phone booth at a gas station and demanded I follow him to a darkened area.

I quickly told the person on the other end of my call to get the police to the corner of Orange Grove Boulevard and Lake Avenue. Then I complied with the assailant's order. But on the walk I managed to pull my hysterical teenager free.

Mr. Blond disappeared into the night.

Pasadena police arrived and, with the description of the assailant, asked me to ride with them as they canvassed the area.

In an alley, their squad car came upon a crouched figure. The short Latino guy was ordered to stand with his hands in the air. I was asked to identify the suspect who wasn't tall, white or blond.

I said he wasn't the culprit, but the police handcuffed him anyway.

Recently Oscar Carrillo — who called in the false 911 report the night his car was allegedly burglarized by a 17-year-old aided by Kendrec McDade (killed later that night by police) — put himself in harm's way when he used his cell phone to make that report.

Carrillo's call, his subsequent arrest for lying about whether his assailants had guns, and his brush with immigration authorities regarding his status in this country, have wrongly placed him front and center in the tragedy that took place when Pasadena police officers Mathew Griffin and Jeff Newlen shot and killed the unarmed 19-year-old McDade.

Carrillo more than likely believed he would get a quicker police response if he reported weapons were used in the burglary. But exaggerating a problem is not an unfamiliar tactic when a person wants to shorten their wait time.

Nor is law enforcement's ability to select a scapegoat anything new.

On March 31 Pasadena Police Chief Sanchez held a meeting at New Revelation Missionary Baptist Church and provided attendees with his department's account of the killing, including a focus on the recording of Carrillo's 911 call.

Carrillo lied. But he did not shoot and kill, as the two officers did.

Like the Latino man in the alley who I watched get cuffed and shoved into a squad car while the blond-haired assailant was left afoot, if Chief Sanchez has his way in focusing on Carrillo's cell phone call, his officers will be left afoot to shoot down more unarmed young black men.

Copyright © 2012, Pasadena Sun








Comment

1. Get them my friend!
- by gloria, 04-18-2012, 8:17 PM

2. Shirlee, I'm thankful that you and your daughter did not get physically hurt in that horrifying encounter. There is undoubtedly anguish and emotional hurt that you're probably both facing. May the perpetrator be caught and brought to justice, and may you and your daughter always be safe and well.
- by Thelma T. Reyna, 04-17-2012, 3:14 PM

3.
All around , this is a tragedy .

One of the PPD Officers shot from his Patrol Car , this isn't feeling unsafe , this was cold blooded MURDER .

I've been a resident of Pasadena for 45 + years and this is the normal way things are handled by the extremely unprofessional PPD . face the facts .

I'm a minor cog in the L.A.P.D.'s Moto Transport Division and our Boys in Blue would be crucified if they did this .

I'm a single parent who worried everyday about my now adult biracial son until he moved away , this is not what America is about .

-Nate
- by -Nate, 04-17-2012, 6:24 AM

4. I think the fundamental question is, "Would the officers have handled McDade differently if the caller had not lied about the gun?" We'll never know, as the PPD is not known for its honesty, integrity, transparency, or professionalism. Sanchez especially seems more interested in garnering publicity for himself than in good policing. This is in stark contrast to the efforts to engage the community and reassess methods made by the recently-retired sheriff's captain in Altadena.

Frankly, I think Carillo ought to be punished, as should anyone who purposely misleads on a 911 call. What if I had been robbed at the same time, a block away, but was honest about what was stolen %28Carillo evidently also lied about having a laptop%29 and that the robbers were unarmed? The police would have been involved with the liar instead of the honest citizen.

That said, the incident and the officers' actions need to be rigorously investigated. The Star-News reports that there are four or five agencies looking into this. I hope they will look deeply into the issue of racial profiling, because indeed, it does exist, and not just on the part of white officers.
- by Laura Monteros, 04-16-2012, 9:00 AM

5. The piece IS informed and illustrative of the same old stuff that has been going on. So tired of whiners defending the stupid, racist cops who kill because they "are in fear"/"believed their lives were in danger"... Cops receive ample training in order to avoid all of these "mistakes" %28which coincidentally seem to always result in a BLACK person's death%29. If you are too timid and in such fear for your safety, then DON'T BE A COP.
- by lisa, 04-16-2012, 8:11 AM

6. Regarding your personal experience with your daughter, you are not the police and have no idea why they handcuffed the Latino man. There was certainly more going on than your reported crime. But as you said that is ancient history. But what isn't ancient history is the media continuing to keep things stirred up while the McDade tragedy is investigated. You state that Carillo is unfairly the scapegoat and that "exaggerating a problem is not an unfamiliar tactic". Stating emphatically that McDade and his friend both had guns is not exaggerating; it is lying. That lie by Carillo was heard on the 911 call, as the dispatcher repeatedly asked him if the suspects were armed. That lie led to police employing tactics that would otherwise not have been used. That lie led to them believing their lives were in danger as McDade ran towards the car. Carillo is hardly the scapegoat. He is the reason this tragedy unfolded as it did. May I suggest you spend an evening on a ride along with Pasadena Police so that you may be a little more informed on how/why they react to calls? And finally , your ending statement about the police shooting "more unarmed black men" is intended to keep things stirred up while police and other agencies continue to investigate. Why is there no outrage for the Armenian unarmed victim who died as he led the LAPD on a pursuit and then faced them as he ran and looked like he was brandishing a weapon. Because he isn't black it didn't fit into your neatly packaged column of prejudice?
Is this prejudicial comment re: unarmed black men what you teach children? Remember,prejudice comes from the word prejudge, something you should be advising people not to do until the investigations re: the McDade case are completed.
- by Marion, 04-15-2012, 10:12 AM